enemy vs swap

K

kintaro

New Member
ok.. now here is the scenario

player A has on the field a face up atk position sangan and a ddwl
player B has a face up atk position bls-eotb and a face down enemy controller

player A is the turn player.. he activates creature swap.. he wants to force his sangan to the opponent ^^
player B chains enemy controller, tributing his bls-eotb and taking control of the opponents sangan

what happens now? ^^

enemy resolves, player B gets the sangan, and the effect of creature swap dissapears, since sangan is no longer in his control?

or

creature swaps effect does not dissapear, and player B gets the ddwl and player A the sangan, after creature swap resolves?

tnx for the answers
 
Sort by date Sort by votes
Ok, here's the scenario and resolution..in detail...lol

Player A has a face-up attack position "Sangan" and "D. D. Warrior Lady".
Player B has a face-up attack position "BLS - EotB" and a face-down "Enemy Controller".
Player A is the turn player.
Player A activates "Creature Swap" with the intent of giving his "Sangan" to Player B.
Player B chains "Enemy Controller", Tributing his "BLS - EotB" and targeting the opponents "Sangan".

Chain:
Step 1: "Creature Swap"
Step 2: "Enemy Controller"

Resolution:
Step 2: "Enemy Controller"
Step 1: "Creature Swap"

"Enemy Controller" resolves, sending "BLS - EotB" to the Graveyard. Player B then takes control of "Sangan".
"Creature Swap" resolves. Player A has only "D. D. Warrior Lady" and Player B has only "Sangan". The monsters switch sides of the field.

Player A now has their original "Sangan" back and Player B now has Player A's "D. D. Warrior Lady".

So Player A got jipped and Player B came out smelling like roses...lol


Does this help kinatro?
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Im pretty sure you are right, that tributing the monster is a cost of Enemy Controller. However, Skey23 put it in both places. Tributing BLS during the activation, then sending it to the Grave during resolution.

I think if you have tributed the monster to activate the effect, it really wouldnt be there later to send to the Graveyard..again,lol. If that 2nd part is taken out (or ignored) then it does make sense.

Good luck on your final. Are you at the last one yet?
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
You are both correct, it IS a cost. I shouldn't have restated it during the resolution part, but I was just trying make a point that "Enemy Controller" DID send "BLS - EotB" to the Graveyard BEFORE anything else happened..lol..

Sorry for any confusion!
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top