forced requisition

[maestro satori]

I just wanted clarification. I think I am correct for all these scenarios. my burn deck is already becomming killer but if any of these are incorrect it will smash.

Forced Requisition will not trigger if active and a controlling player discards for Type Zero Magic Crusher correct?

-will not trigger if active and the controlling player discards for Dragged Down into the Grave correct?

-will not trigger if active and the controlling player discards for Magic Jammer correct?

 

[Digital Jedi]

I can't see why any of those wouldn't work. Forced Requisition says "each time you discard a card from your hand" and each effect you mentioned has you "discarding" a card.

 

[maestro satori]

was told the last thing that happens must be a discard for forced requisition to activate. but that is why I am asking.

 

[chaosruler]

wow, correct on ALL counts for maestro satori, the last thing to happen in a chain MUST be the discard, so Type Zero Magic Crusher won't do it (500 damage is last thing to happen), DDitG won't work (drawing is the last thing), and for Magic Jammer (the last thing to happen is the negation of the Spell card)

EDIT: misunderstood the question, if you are trying to ACTIVATE Forced Requistion, then you cannot in the above scenarios, but if it is already active, then it WILL trigger in each case, sorry guys ^_^

-chaosruler

 

[removefromp]

I think they will all trigger the effect of forced requisition.

I think FR's effect is more or less very likely to magical thorn. whenever ur opponent discards from his hand, he takes 500 damage for magical. by the same token, whenever u discard from your hand, ur opponent discard a card from his hand for FR.

For dragged down into the grave, ur opponent discard after he draws.


a follow up question: when u activate graceful charity when you have a forced requistion active on the field, does ur opponent discard 1 or 2 cards?

 

[chaosruler]

for graceful, they discard 2, and i edited my post like mad

-chaosruler

 

[removefromp]

for some reason, I also heard that in order for FR to work, discarding must be the last thing that happens. if thats true, wouldn't FR's effect not triggered for jammer,etc.?

could it be the wordings of the card that makes FR works differently than magical thorn.

FR: each time you discard from your handeach time you discard from your hand...
MT: When your opponent's card(s) in his/her hand are discarded to the Graveyard...

 

[chaosruler]

in order to ACTIVATE forced requistion (i.e. flip the card over and literally activate it) then discard must be the last thing to occur. Otherwise, for effect activation, it DOES NOT follow the same pattern.

-chaosruler

 

[removefromp]

so theres only a condition that the discarding must be the last thing that happens in order for the player to activate FR, but as long as FR is active on the field already, the discarding no longer need to be the last thing in order for FR's effect to trigger?

am I right this time?

 

[removefromp]

I am so confused now. lets say i activate card destruction when I have a FR active on my field. does it mean that the effect of FR "disappers" becasue opponent has no card in his hand when FR's effect(when I discard, my oppoent discards) is resolving.

 

[chaosruler]

correct

-chaosruler

 

[removefromp]

if your opponent activates deliquent duo. can I activate FR after I discard 1 card or do I have to wait until I discard 2 cards for DD then activate FR?

if the discarding has to be the last thing that happenes for FR to activate, does it mean I cannot activate FR if after I discard for Deliquent duo, my opponent uses his pirority to activate lets say a ring of destruction?

 

[chaosruler]

um, he cannot interrupt the rsolution of a chain, and you have priority to activate any Spell Speed 2 or up card you wish

-chaosruler

 

[removefromp]

ic...hey thanks for your input chaosruler. ^^

 

[Digital Jedi]

To simplify matters:

In order to activate Forced Requisition (flip it face-up) you have to wait for an effect where the last thing to happen is discarding from your hand.

Once face-up, each time you discard for an effect Forced Requisition's continuous effect will activate forcing your opponent to discard.

It always has to be a discard effect and not a "send a card from your hand to the graveyard" or "destroy card(s) in your hand" effect.

 

[maestro satori]

So my example of FR active and type zero magic crusher would cause an opponent to discard? so my adding in my magical thorn will make me a very evil person....500 per spell type zero and 500 for MT. if your are wondering I have alot of spells that can cause damage on thier own but IF I need the opponents hand advantage down bam. have new q1uestion but needs it's own thread