Hey if this happened to you?

[DonZaloog25]

This happened to a friend of mine at our local tourney, and what happened was that my friend and his opponent both forgot who won game one, so the head judge, decides to flip a coin, which I think is unfair because they couldn't remeber it so, the way I would have dealt with it is to give a double game loss, and make the players play a Sudden Death game to be fair I just think the judge was doing this improperly and I just wanted to know what you guys thought.

 

[Barty64]

I also think this is unfair as it could cause prblems later on so i think it should have gone to sudden death or just have one more duel to decide the winner.

 

[Teufelhunden]

I have never heard of a match being decided by a coin flip nor can it be found in any rule book. As neither player obviously kept track of life points, I would have ruled a game loss for both players and given them both warnings. Players are required to keep track of life points.

 

[Deathjester]

And have a good enough memory to at least remember who won. o_0

 

[Digital Jedi]

At a premiere event, I'm willing to be they would have been issued a double game loss and no sudden death match. <Wondering what would John have done>

 

[Evil Fiber Jar]

At a premiere event, I'm willing to be they would have been issued a double game loss and no sudden death match. <Wondering what would John have done>

I would have to agree with Digital Jedi. If either players can't remember who won, I would give them a double game loss and then continue with the match. It should be there responsibility to keep track of both players life points.

 

[roadhouse007]

I also agree. Give a double game loss, and let them play game 3 out. If game 3 went into time or began after time was called, then end of match procedure (not sudden death).But ONLY if it was after time should have been or was called.

EDIT: I realized I put (sudden death) instead of (not suddden death). WHAT WAS I THINKING!!!