Reinforcements of the Army Question
from UDE's Player Management Forums
1)Player A has a Gemini Elf on the field, and Reinforcements of the army in his hand.
Player B has a Pheonix Wing Wind Blast set on the Field.
Player B Activates Pheonix wing, returning Gemini Elf to the top of the deck.
Player A Actvates Reinforcement of the Army, only to find that he has no warriors remaining in his deck. Player B varifies.
Since this is a Repairable game state. Reinforcement of the army would be return to his hand (since it couldn't be activated), Gemini Elf would be set asside, Player A's Deck shuffled, then Gemini Elf Returned to the top of the deck.
Is this Right?
2)Player A Has 2 Reinforcements of the army in hand.
Player B has a Solemn Judgment on the field.
Player A plays Reinforcement of the Army, Player B uses Solemn Judgment.
Player A Activates his 2nd Reinforcements of the Army. Searches deck and finds no warriors.
Since he had no Warrior, Reinforcements of the Army is returned to his hand. But in his case, the Original Reinforcement of the Army could not have been activated.
What happens? Does the orginial reinforcements return, along with the solemn judgment (and 1/2 Player's B LP)? Or was the 1st reinforcements a valid play?
http://entertainment.upperdeck.com/community/forums/thread/1200794.aspx
from UDE's Player Management Forums
1)Player A has a Gemini Elf on the field, and Reinforcements of the army in his hand.
Player B has a Pheonix Wing Wind Blast set on the Field.
Player B Activates Pheonix wing, returning Gemini Elf to the top of the deck.
Player A Actvates Reinforcement of the Army, only to find that he has no warriors remaining in his deck. Player B varifies.
Since this is a Repairable game state. Reinforcement of the army would be return to his hand (since it couldn't be activated), Gemini Elf would be set asside, Player A's Deck shuffled, then Gemini Elf Returned to the top of the deck.
Is this Right?
2)Player A Has 2 Reinforcements of the army in hand.
Player B has a Solemn Judgment on the field.
Player A plays Reinforcement of the Army, Player B uses Solemn Judgment.
Player A Activates his 2nd Reinforcements of the Army. Searches deck and finds no warriors.
Since he had no Warrior, Reinforcements of the Army is returned to his hand. But in his case, the Original Reinforcement of the Army could not have been activated.
What happens? Does the orginial reinforcements return, along with the solemn judgment (and 1/2 Player's B LP)? Or was the 1st reinforcements a valid play?
http://entertainment.upperdeck.com/community/forums/thread/1200794.aspx