Two questions
from UDE's Player Management Forums
Hello all,
A judge in my area is trying to get set up to post on here, but in the interim, he asked me to post this for him. I thought that the questions were very good, and other people might also benefit from a discussion of the situations, so here we go.
#1 Double dropping resource
At the start of player A’s turn he places a resource for turn. At the end of player A’s turn he plays another resource.
#2 Searching your deck (manipulation)
The Missing Diplomat
During your turn, pay 4 to complete this quest.
Reward: Search your deck for an ally card, reveal it, and put it into your hand.
Player A completes Missing Diplomat. While searching through his deck Player A finds 5 cards and removes them from his deck, he then compares the 5 cards to his hand and in play zone as if making a touch decision on what to select. He then reveals one of the 5 cards as his choice and puts the other cards back into this library.
http://entertainment.upperdeck.com/community/forums/thread/1204209.aspx
from UDE's Player Management Forums
Hello all,
A judge in my area is trying to get set up to post on here, but in the interim, he asked me to post this for him. I thought that the questions were very good, and other people might also benefit from a discussion of the situations, so here we go.
#1 Double dropping resource
At the start of player A’s turn he places a resource for turn. At the end of player A’s turn he plays another resource.
- <LI class=MsoNormal>If both resources are face down and a judge is called will this be a game loss for player A?
- If both player A and B recognize which face down resource was played in addition to the first and still call a judge over will this be a warning for player A and not a game loss?
- It is the beginning of turn 5 for player A. Player A also went first in this game. Player A places his 5th resource for the turn and asks how many his opponent has. Player B also has five resources. Because player A has written down turn count what will happen when a judge is called?
#2 Searching your deck (manipulation)
The Missing Diplomat
During your turn, pay 4 to complete this quest.
Reward: Search your deck for an ally card, reveal it, and put it into your hand.
Player A completes Missing Diplomat. While searching through his deck Player A finds 5 cards and removes them from his deck, he then compares the 5 cards to his hand and in play zone as if making a touch decision on what to select. He then reveals one of the 5 cards as his choice and puts the other cards back into this library.
- When Player A returns the 4 unselected cards to his deck he evenly spaces them through out this deck. This could be viewed as deck manipulation (taking 4 removal spells + 1 ally from the deck, taking the ally and returning the removal spells evenly to the deck etc.). What can I do as a player if I see something similar going on and what action would the judge take if any.
http://entertainment.upperdeck.com/community/forums/thread/1204209.aspx