soul exchange

StRiKe_NiNjA

Dimension Shift Ninja
Soul Exchange
SDY-041
Normal Spell
Select 1 monster on your opponent's side of the field. When you offer your monster as a Tribute, offer the selected monster in place of 1 of your monsters. During this turn, you cannot conduct your Battle Phase.

how do you exactly use this card?

does the word Tribute mean just ony Tribute Summons?
 
You activate this card during your turn. Later that turn, when you offer one of your monsters as a Tribute (for a Tribute Summon, for a Ritual Summon, for the effect of [Cannon Soldier] or any other effect that says "Tribute"), then instead of Tributing your own monster, you can Tribute your opponent's monster instead. Their monster gets sent to the Graveyard instead of the one you would have Tributed.

EXAMPLE
My opponent has [Kaiser Seahorse] on the field. I can activate [Soul Exchange], select his [Kaiser Seahorse] and offer that as a Tribute to Tribute Summon [Jinzo] (or a higher level LIGHT monster, because you can still use the effect of [Kaiser Seahorse] as considering it to be 2 Tributes for a Tribute Summon).

EXAMPLE
I have [Cannon Soldier] on the field. I can activate [Soul Exchange], select an opponent's monster and offer that as a Tribute for the effect of [Cannon Soldier].

Now, the one downside to this card is that you cannot conduct your Battle Phase during the turn you use this card. Also, if you've already conducted your Battle Phase this turn, you cannot then activate [Soul Exchange]. So don't try to be too sneaky about it. I mean, come on, getting rid of an opponent's monster for a stronger one of your own? Half the time it'd set you up for a Direct Attack, and that'd be too broken if you could attack with it in the same turn.

Please correct me if I'm wrong, but [Soul Exchange] creates a state similar to [Last Will]. You must activate it before the Tribute (/destruction), but you can use the effect of the card any time after the activation until the end of your same turn. But only once may you use its effect.

If so, I assume [Soul Exchange] would work with [Ectoplasmer]?
 
Maruno said:
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but [Soul Exchange] creates a state similar to [Last Will]. You must activate it before the Tribute (/destruction), but you can use the effect of the card any time after the activation until the end of your same turn. But only once may you use its effect.
This is correct.

Maruno said:
If so, I assume [Soul Exchange] would work with [Ectoplasmer]?
Yes it will.

In addition, you don't have to have a monster on your side of the field to use Soul Exchange, but your opponent should have at least one monster on his side of the field for you to target. If both of you and your opponent each have one monster on each side of the field, you can use Soul Exchange and then tribute both monster to summon a 2 tribute monster.

It is still debatable if the monster targeted by Soul Exchange happens to be Kaiser Seahorse (and the likes). I still don't know if you can tribute him to bring out level 7 or more light monster.

Here is a link to a topic previously posted. http://nforums.netrep.net/index.php?topic=889.msg5826#msg5826
 
I should think you could use the effect of your opponent's [Kaiser Seahorse], [The Trojan Horse], etc. if you use [Soul Exchange] on it, because you're the one doing the Tributing. If you Tribute for a LIGHT, EARTH, etc. monster with that, you should be able to use its effect. The monster is only "being treated as" 2 Tributes, so it is still technically just 1 Tribute, which goes into the effect of [Soul Exchange] quite nicely.

Just my opinion, though. Don't go using that as an excuse to play questionable games now.
 
I think it should work. However, others view this differently. They said that Kaiser Seahorse (and the likes) ability to use him for 2 tribute is his effect. Soul Exchange only allows you to tribute him, but not to use his effect because technically, you are not controlling him. This is why this issue is still debatable.
 
That seems correct, it most likely specifically has to do with Kaiser Seahorse's text being more of a "condition" on the monster rather than an effect. It can still apply, even though you do not control the monster.
 
How about combo with Share the Pain?? Use them both to destroy TWO of your opponent's monsters?

Quick Question: Can Share the Pain be used like Soul Exchange for a tribute summon? or is the tribute for no apparent reason except card text?
 
Since "Share the Pain" says "tribute" you can "Soul Exchange" your opponent's monster and use that instead. However, they would have to have 2 monsters on their side of the field at the least otherwise you'd be forced to use your own.

And no. You offer your monster as the cost to activate "Share the Pain" (so if they "Magic Jammer" it, you're out of luck). Like anything else, you can't offer a "tribute" to accomplish 2 tribute items at once.

- A
 
Back
Top