Search results

  1. M

    Compulsory Evacuation Device vs. Creature Swap

    I can only say what I use to say when I'm asked about my exams: "I refuse to say anything until I talk with my lawyer." Knowing about priority after every action in Yu-Gi-Oh! is becoming a nightmare. I suggest and go for a resolution of "Turn player goes first", but this concept is just...
  2. M

    Best of three wins?

    Good information. Gotta take some notes. Well. I don't agree with the bold part. The policy says that "the match winner will be determined by the first change in life points." In a turn, there could be a lot of changes in life points. I think that there is no need to wait until the end of turn...
  3. M

    Two Scapegoat during the same turn

    Sorry, but using Scapegoat implies Special Summoning the Sheep Tokens. Then, you cannot activate a second Scapegoat the same turn, because it is a Special Summon. A Special Summon is forced when you don't decide to do that. Example: Your face-down Cyber Jar was flipped. By the effect of Cyber...
  4. M

    Black Luster Soldier- Envoy Effect

    But, "Black Luster Soldier - Envoy of the Beginning" resets its conditions when it is removed from the field. You're right in the fact that it can only use its effects once per turn. But, if "Black Luster Soldier - Envoy of the Beginning" is returned by "Compulsory Evacuation Device" after it...
  5. M

    Negates one Waboku then the guy activates another. Legal? Yes/No? Why?

    Sorry, but, some months ago, Mr. Kevin surprised most of us saying that it is possible to have more than one chain when responding to an attack. The restriction is that there are some cards that can only be activated in the first chain, the chain that responds to the declaration of the attack...
  6. M

    Chaos Sorceror vs Bottomless

    Read the Priority v. 1.1 first thread by helpoemer 316. The exact case of Bottomless vs. Breaker the Magical Warrior is right there in the section "CARDS THAT A PLAYER HAS NO PRIORITY WITH:" That should get things clear.
  7. M

    Question about Continuous Trap Cards

    OK, I want to ask something. People tend to think that an Equip Magic Card and a Continuous Trap Card that targets a monster are the same. But they aren't. I want to get definitely all the differences between them. - First, Equip Magic Cards only target face-up monsters. Some Continuous Trap...
  8. M

    book of life

    Yes, Book of Life targets a Zombie-type monster in your graveyard, but that doesn't matter for Spirit Reaper, because: "¢ Spirit Reaper is only destroyed by its own effect if it is face-up on the field when the effect designating it as a target activates, AND after the effect designating it as...
  9. M

    Share the Pain

    I asked about Share the Pain a time ago: The card text should have its text updated later, when Metal Raiders gets analyzed or if the card gets to appear in Dark Revelation, maybe.
  10. M

    Staunch Defender Debate

    I would say that it does change the positions. The card could have specified "face-up Attack Position monsters" if that weren't the case, and there is not any errata reported. And the combo Ojama Trio - Staunch Defender - Labyrinth Wall seems right, pretty right.
  11. M

    Pyramid of Light Question

    Of course. "Skill Drain" doesn't look at not face-up cards on the field, leaving a difference in its reach and Imperial Order's reach where the negated cards don't have to be face-up on the field. I made a bad analogy using Skill Drain. Sorry about that. OK, then, let's say during the time that...
  12. M

    Pyramid of Light Question

    OK, then we can say, in the meanwhile, that these effects occur on the field itself and Jinzo and Royal Decree will negate them. We have considered the case in which the card is just "destroyed" in the "removed from your side of the field" part. Now, the case in which the card is returned to...
  13. M

    Priority v. 1.1

    Re: Priority v. 1.1 (All Read before posting priority quest.) OK, it seems that this strange and painful case will be resolved. But, there will be more mysteries and doubts to come in the next chapter, jujujuajaja. :evil: OK, now getting into the topic, ¿Do you know how many times I've thrown...
  14. M

    Pyramid of Light Question

    Exactly. That thread. I wrote an e-mail in October 30 to the lists about that, but, as you said, it got "lost" or they have deleted it, either by mistake or because they are now :bishop: .
  15. M

    Pyramid of Light Question

    My old question about Dark Magician of Chaos is "lost" too. I will try to post it this time directly in the page forums, not through e-mail, just in case, but it shouldn't even matter.
  16. M

    Pyramid of Light Question

    I don't know. I found this ruling of Big Bang Shot while looking for an answer: When "Imperial Order" is active, and you destroy "Big Bang Shot" with "Dust Tornado", the effect of "Big Bang Shot" that would remove the monster from play is NOT applied. The same thing happens with, for example...
  17. M

    change of heart after cyber jar.

    If you want the exact procedure, look at this topic: http://nforums.netrep.net/index.php/topic,692.0.html Hope this makes things clear about the Cyber Jar procedure. I've seen a lot of time people trying to use Change of Heart to get these type of monsters just after the Cyber Jar resolves...
  18. M

    Questions about IO, Soul Exchange, and Horus LV6

    Just to add; Dillie-O was correct, you can't use an effect that will do nothing, like Dark Hole with no monsters or Heavy Storm without other Magic/Traps, since Heavy Storm doesn't count itself. [I'm not counting any possible exceptions] I just seem to disagree in the last point, looking at...
  19. M

    Relinquished Ruling Official?

    :? From what I know (Game Boy Advance, it might be wrong  :-P) you equip the monster in the EXACT position it was, attack or defense. Then, if the monster is in defense mode, it should be very easy to distinguish it along the face-down Magic/Traps. This kind of confusion should appear only with...
  20. M

    Severely need an official ruling on this...

    :| Ejem. First, yugioh-card.com and netrep.net have the official rulebook online. Second, the ruling of Different Dimension Gate provides the answer: "You can select a Monster Token when you activate "Different Dimension Gate", but the token is destroyed." The same will happen if...
Back
Top