Search results

Well obviously since I made no mention of video games, I will just respond with, get your head out the real game's ass. You have no proof to prove you are correct in your assumption on how it works. All I see is from the CoG people are contradictory statements, avoiding certain issues, bypassing...

Read the link's diagram. We enter the Battle Phase. We have turn priority. Now before we even declare an attack we have some other form of priority EVEN BEFORE WE DECLARED AN ATTACK, then we move to Sub-Step 3 and declare our attack and what not. That is not only confusing, but contradictory...

Uh because we just magically shift from entering the Battle Phase, me wanting to activate a card thanks to my turn priority to use jumping into the Battle Step without me even declaring an attack or doing anything after I used up my priority from entering the Battle Phase in the first place...

Right..... so obviously even before I declare an attack I get some mystical 2nd chance at priority. No thanks. I rather have something more update.

Define "my" tournaments. As in you organize it, you notice the same players winning and being the top 8 and the other players get discourage and do not bother to enter?

The first part with the Battle Step is confusing. You have priority when you enter the Battle Phase to activate a card like Call of the Haunted for example. Yet he lists for the Battle Step Sub-Step 1 you have priority to activate say a Call of the Haunted? How do you move from entering the...

There is no reason that fully explains what exactly is the Battle Step. It would be confusing to just say it all happens in the same phase and try to sell me that the Battle Step is basically this mini-phase in the Battle Phase that has its own rules, similiar to the Main Phase 1 where we can...

There is nothing to debate. It was answered. It was explained. Accept it. That is like refusing to accept that humans have hearts, and until you open a person up to verify it, it aint true.

Not to mention, Curtis is the rulings guy.

Digital, the thing is you are saying contradictory statements. You say the Battle Step begins with the declaration of an attack and ends when you enter the Damage Step. Then how do you even stay in the Battle Step when a Counter Trap ends the chain? You should and would automatically enter the...

Well you need those Hero Flash!! cards and stuff from EOJ if you even hope to have a competitve E-Hero Deck. Then you need to decide on which Fusions you want to focus on.

That does not apply when in Battle. You have to progress throughout the step. Unlike the Main Phase for example I could just sit on my butt and stay in it for the end of time for all I care. When I declare an attack I have to proceed.

Deck is too inconsistent. Here is why it is wrong to even consider Reinforcement of the Army over the Elemental Hero support cards from HERO Flash!!. How many Warrior-Type you got in the Deck? How many Warrior-Type you got in the Deck that is not a E-Hero? See my point. Use the Hero Flash...

If it happens in the same step as you say Jedi. How do you explain the Battle Step then? How do you go from declaring attack, activating a Trap or Spell Card in response to the attack, have a Counter Trap negate it. Then you move onto this mysterious place before the Damage Step where one can...

Because the declaration of an attack and the actual "Battle Step" are two different things. They may happen technically in the same step, but they are two things that have their own rules. I made an example earlier in the post about how one would progress in a fight. I declare that I want to...

You might want to correct that because Book of Moon is being activated in the same step as Mirror Force? If that was the case clearly Mirror Force would have been activated after Trap Jammer resolves since it is clearly happening in the same step.

Digital is this just assumption or does the rule book go into depth that this only applies "declaration type of cards?" If this is just the same battle step (declaring an attack) then how exactly would explain the above scenario when P2 was able to use Book of Moon? Here is an example, replace...

[Example 1] of an OK play. P1 attacks with "Gemini Elf". P2 activates "Sakuretsu Armor". P1 chains "Royal Decree". P2 chains "Mirror Force". [Example 2] of an OK play. P1 attacks with "Gemini Elf". P2 activates "Sakuretsu Armor". P1 activates "Trap Jammer". Chain resolves. P2...

I am not talking about the summon. Did you read the OK and ILLEGAL examples when to declare an attack? There is the step of declaring an attack, then once get past that, you go to the Battle Step, hence is why in that example after Trap Jammer resolved, P2 was able to Book of Moon the monster.

http://lists.upperdeck.com/read/messages?id=9278 Pretty much states how and what can and cannot be done when you declare an attack, which is essentially its own Step to begin with, then moving onto the Battle Step itself.