BIG BANG SHOT

[ANIKY]

When the card says: "...removed from the field..." minds that it is equiped whit a monster and i use giant trunade its monster is removed from play?

 

[novastar]

I understand what you are saying, but the "Robbin'" cards state the MONSTER must inflict the Battle Damage. With "Big Bang Shot", the MONSTER is not doing any damage at all, "Big Bang Shot" is. It's dealing Battle Damage through IT'S EFFECT.

With "Amazoness Swordswoman" or "Spear Dragon", or any other monster that has an effect that 'tramples', or does Battle Damage, the Battle Damage is STILL coming from the monster, even if it's the effect of the monster, it's still 'originating' from the monster, which satisfies the TEXT REQUIREMENT of the "Robbin'" cards.

Do you see what I'm saying?

If the "Robbin'" cards stated: "When your opponent takes Battle Damage..." I wouldn't have ANY issue with cards like "Big Bang Shot" or "Fairy Meteor Crush" being able to activate their effect, but as the wording states on the cards now, I have an issue with it.

[edit]..he he he..nova just came back online. I'm prolly about to be given the 'SMACKDOWN'...he he he...

[edit]..aww man..he's gone again.....I guess I'll have to wait til later.

The Equip Cad is giving the monster the ability to "trample", so the Battle Damage is still being inflicted by the monster itself.

If you control a Robbin' Goblin it will Trigger when one of your monsters equipped with Big Bang Shot inflicts Battle Damage.

 

[skey23]

Ok. That makes the most sense in my feeble little brain.

Thanks!