krazykidpsx said:
Darn, too late. lol
like Dlanaan said, book of moon can only target faceup monsters.
so the first one wouldnt work.
the second would work. the chain(s) would look like this.
player 1 declares an attack
player 2 activates desert sunlight.
player 2's MEB activates its effect killing 1 monster.
Player 1's monster is now attackaing
player 2 chains book of moon on MEB
Player1's monster now hits the face down MEB.
I really really really hope that is how the play looks.
Well, just to correct the wording because you are not chaining to the attack (attacks like summons have no speed so they can't be chained to). The ruling was chained though so that you can start multiple chains in the Battle Phase. It's why the following scenario works:
Player 1 declares an attack with his "Gemini Elf" on Player 2's face up "Magician of Faith".
Player 2 activates "Magic Cylinder"
Player 1 chains "Trap Jammer".
Player 2 passes, the chain resolves with "Trap Jammer" negating "Magic Cylinder".
Now there is still the attack pending, but the "state" now is "Chain Resolved", so Player 2 can't activate "Mirror Force" or "Draining Shield" since they can only be activated when the attack is declared and that chain hasn't resolved. However, Player 2 instead decides to activate "Waboku" (starting a new chain). Player 1 passes, "Waboku" resolves and no battle damage is taken so "Magician of Faith" remains on the field.
Now, 1 other thing wrong with the above example. Since the opponent is attacking, "Book of Moon" can't be played from your hand. It would have to be set on the field. So if we change that, here's how it would work:
Player 1 has "Gemini Elf" and "Slate Warrior"
Player 2 has a face-down defense "Man-Eater Bug", and a set "Desert Sunlight" and "Book of Moon"
Player 1 declares an attack with "Gemini Elf"
Player 2 activates "Desert Sunlight"
Player 1 passes, "Desert Sunlight" resolves, flipping "Man-Eater Bug".
The attack is still pending at this point. "Man-Eater Bug"'s effect activates, starts a new chain. Player 1 passes and the effect resolves. Player 2 chooses to destroy "Slate Warrior".
The attack is still pending after the 2nd chain. Player 2 activates "Book of Moon" and flips "Man-Eater Bug" face down.
With no other chains activated at this point, the attack finally goes through with "Gemini Elf" attacking and destroying "Man-Eater Bug". "Man-Eater Bug" is reflipped, his effect activates again, and this time "Gemini Elf" is destroyed.
There you go. And like I said before, deck ideas have just opened up :evil:
- Andrew