More End Phase headaches!

skey23

Council of Heroes
Ok, since we're doing End Phase resolutions and what not...here's one I'm 'stealing' from another site because it's brought up a few questions in my mind that I'm not entirely sure how to resolve...lol.

P1 has a face-up "Gemini Elf" and a face-down "Archfiend Soldier", on the field.
P1 also has an "Enemy Controller" set from a previous turn.
P2 has no monsters and "Brain Control" in hand.
P2 activates "Brain Control", paying the 800 LPs, and targeting "Gemini Elf".
P1 does not respond.
P2 does not respond.
P2 now has control of "Gemini Elf".
P2 moves to Battle Phase and declares attack with "Gemini Elf".
P1 responds with "Enemy Controller", choosing the 2nd effect and tributing their face-down monster to take control of "Gemini Elf".
P2 does not respond.
P1 does not respond.
P1 now has "Gemini Elf" again.
P2 ends their turn.

Ok, so how does this resolve?

Can P2 even resolve the effect of "Brain Control" if the monster is no longer on their side of the field?

The 'ideal' resolution would be this:
P2 retains Priority to resolve "Brain Control", but passes.
P1 chooses to resolve "Enemy Controller" and "Gemini Elf" goes back to P2.
P2 now must resolve "Brain Control" and "Gemini Elf" goes back to P1.
End turn.

But what happens when P2 tries to resolve "Brain Control" w/o actually having control of the monster?

Alternate resolution:
P2 retains Priority to resolve "Brain Control" but passes.
P1 Passes on resolving "Enemy Controller".
P2 MUST resolve "Brain Control", but there is no monster. "Brain Control"s effect disappears?
P1 now resolves "Enemy Controller" and P2 gets "Gemini Elf" where it will stay since "Brain Control"s effect has been forced to activate already?

THIS is truly confusing..lol.
 
Also keep in mind that in that case now, after you resolve Change of Heart, you are now dealing with a face-down monster. That might actually have affected the situation, because turning the monster face-down makes it unknown and removes control factors, just like when a Snatched monster gets turned face-down.

If the monster had remained face-up and Snatch Steal were to be destroyed by MST, the situation might have worked out differently.

It is interesting though, it's always been a little weird with this and they have never really had a consistant pattern (as with most things).
 
Could you clear something up for me, please? I have recreated the senario with a few minor alterations (sorry skey23) and a list of possibilities to help me grasp what is exactly going on. If any of these things are known quantities, either yes or no, please help me weed them down to fewer options. If I missed any questions, please help with that too. Here is how I understand the questions being asked about the end phase.

Questions Regarding End Phase and End of lingering effects.



You, Turn Player have 5 monsters on the Field, you destroy your own Twin-Headed behemoth with Raigeki Break and play Asura Priest. Before you attack, your opponent activates Enemy Controller, sacrificing one of his monsters to take control of your Asura Priest. You activate Mind Control to take it back. Just for kicks, let's have the opponent also activate Archfiend's Roar to special summon Archfiend Soldier. You attack and do lots of nice damage (no other effects are applied). When you enter your end Phase, what is the proper way to handle all of the effects? Specifically:

Is there a difference in handling activating effects, like Twin-Headed Behemoth and ending effects, like Enemy Controller?

Do they operate like Prioity"”if so, how? With Turn Player doing every manditory efffect first, then the Opponent? Or do they pass priority/response back and forth?

Or do all of the effects chain, as they are all trying to end at the same time? If so, how?

Or do they all resolve/end in the order/reverse order they were activated, or resolved?



Does this quite cover the possible questions? Inquiring minds want to know.
 
DarkLogicianOfCaos said:
Is there a difference in handling activating effects, like Twin-Headed Behemoth and ending effects, like Enemy Controller?
No.
DarkLogicianOfCaos said:
Do they operate like Prioity"”if so, how? With Turn Player doing every manditory efffect first, then the Opponent? Or do they pass priority/response back and forth?
They will pass back and forth, with the Turn Player getting to choose 1st if they wish to activate/resolve, or pass to the opponent.
DarkLogicianOfCaos said:
Or do all of the effects chain, as they are all trying to end at the same time? If so, how?
No.
DarkLogicianOfCaos said:
Or do they all resolve/end in the order/reverse order they were activated, or resolved?
No.
 
In other words, in the senario above, you can choose to send Asura Priest back to your your opponent's side of the field, and pass to him. Then he can either destroy his Archfiend Soldier or send your Asura Priest back, or pass. Either way, you can call your Asura priest back to your hand before special summoning Twin Headed Behemoth, then, if he has any remaining effects, he must resolve them, because you have nothing left. Right?

Now, what about not being able to discard before a spirit monster comes back?

Is it because discarding is suposed to be the last thing you do in your end phase? I know it isn't always the last thing you do, because if you discard your Night Assailant, you get a flip effect card back (or course, you'll still have to discard again, but it is still activating an effect which interupts the proper final event of your turn).

Man, I'm sorry if these questions are lame.
 
Dan is beginning to grow on me, he seems to like being a little more technical. I love to be able to talk to him.

Well looks like the monster being face-up makes a difference: http://lists.upperdeck.com/read/messages?id=9307

The owner was the last player to permanently control the monster, so he/she retains control after all the temporary control factors are removed. (also the monster remained face-up through the whole process).

The only case where the "owner" really comes into play is when a monster is removed from play and then returned without a Special Summon, like in the case of Strike Ninja or IMT. In that case all control characteristics have been stripped through the removal process, and once brought back to the field, it defaults to the owner's control because the rules dictate that and the monster was not Special Summoned (which would give control by mechanic).

That is my understanding, of course it's just a generalization, there will always be strange situations that need patching.
 
Back
Top