Random Musings: The Restrict List

Status
Not open for further replies.
Continuing from the last post, we're going to dive into the most complicated section, the Restrict List. A fair number of cards could swing either way from here to either being banned outright to becoming Semi or Unrestricted. Like last time, let's get the easy ones out of the way.

Call of the Haunted; Card Destruction; Ceasefire; Crush Card Virus; Elemental Hero Stratos; Exodia the Forbidden One; Future Fusion; Gravity Bind; Green Baboon, Defender of the Forest; Jinzo; Left Arm of the Forbidden One; Left Leg of the Forbidden One; Level Limit - Area B; Mage Power; Magic Cylinder; Magical Stone Excavation; Neo-Spacian Grand Mole; Night Assailant; Pot of Avarice; Premature Burial; Protector of the Sanctuary; Right Arm of the Forbidden One; Right Leg of the Forbidden One; Spirit Reaper; Swords of Revealing Light; Torrential Tribute; Twin-Headed Behemoth; Ultimate Offering; United We Stand.

They're all staying where they are. The Exodia Limbs have an outside chance of becoming Semi/Unrestricted one day because of UDE's efforts, but chances are they'll stay where they are. The rest pretty much are just following status quo.

As for the rest, this will be fairly tricky. There are a lot of different possibilities that could change a card's future as of September. That said, let's tackle the rest.

Book of Moon - A lot of people want to see this card become unrestricted once again and view it as a solution to the rampant Brain Control usage in many decks. Many also view it as a solution to combatting Monarchs due to their weak defense. If Tsukuyomi comes off the restrict list, this card will likely stay at 1. If Magician of Faith comes off, this card will likely stay at 1. If Brain Control is restricted, this card will likely stay at 1. Otherwise at best, you're looking at Semi-Restriction.

Chain Strike - When run in 3, this card helped anchor a very quick and powerful (though not always consistant) Burn deck. After restricting it, the deck type has about disappeared, though some still try their hand with it since its potential for damage is stronger than most other cards out there. While likely to stay where it is, a Semi-Restriction would not be that surprising to get give the deck a little more strength, while still not making it as easy to pull 2 at the same time.

Confiscation - This card could be viewed as one of the "necessary evils". It trades the advantage of Delinquent Duo for the knowledge of the player's hand and its cost makes it more prohibitive than The Forceful Sentry (though barely at that). The fate of this card is somewhat tied to how they want to handle Trap Dustshoot and Mind Crush. If Mind Crush becomes Semi/Unrestricted, Confiscation could return back to being Banned. That's also a possibility if they decide they don't want practically free looks at the hand with this being Banned again and Trap Dustshoot becoming Restricted. Most likely though, this will stay where it is.

D.D. Warrior Lady - Could she be in for a Semi-Restriction like D.D. Assailant was on the last list? Probably not. Since you control her when to use her effect, she's an effective tool for removing cards you don't want to see come back while D.D. Assailant is far more limited in that regard. Further with Exiled Force being playable in 3s again, other options are available (though perhaps not as permanent). While she and the other Warriors have seen less play over the past few seasons, I believe the changes that will be made could cause them to reappear as a strong theme type (and admit it, they're not bad now, just other things run faster). Making her more playable in this case will likely have a negative effect so, she'll be staying here.

Dark Magician of Chaos - A few months ago I would have said this card was a lock to being banned. Now, it's not quite as likely anymore. If he is banned, it would likely be because they wanted to wipe out all easy Spell Retrieval cards. With the arrival of new Dark Magician support cards, he could appear in more dedicated and theme decks so he may stay restricted just for that facet. It's about 50-50 right now that he could take a short hiatus or simply stay where he is.

Dimension Fusion - A few months ago, I was even more likely to say this card would have been banned than even Dark Magician of Chaos. With Sky Scourge Norleras not quite lighting the meta on fire and DDT themed decks all about disappeared, that would seem to give this card a little more life. However, Return decks could return to high level play easily enough (depending on other changes) anchored by this card and Dark Magician of Chaos. I have a strong feeling that one of these 2 are going to disappear for awhile and I would say it would be this one.

Giant Trunade - Initially Semi and then Fully Restricted because of its ease in helping OTKs. The fate of this card will rest solely on the fate of Heavy Storm and Harpie's Feather Duster. (See Heavy Storm for more info).

Heavy Storm - Some could view this as another "necessary evil". Some think this will get banned so Harpie's Feather Duster could come back. Other's think it could get banned altogether, which in turn should Semi/Unrestrict Giant Trunade (since there would be no other mass non-themed S/T removal, albeit temporary). Structure Decks have often been a way to predict what could be banned and such based on the cards in them. Heavy Storm is not in the the forthcoming SD13. Granted, there was 1 other Structure Deck where it did not appear, but it just feels different this time. This would be a radical move that would give players far more freedom to overextend in the back should this card be banned without a replacement. Because of that, it may end up staying put. Don't be suprised to see this card become banned sooner than later though.

Jinzo - 99% likely to stay where he is, but it's possible that he could have a status change just to shake things up a little.

Limiter Removal - There are so many annoying things with Machine Decks right now and this card can easily be included in that list. Given that Machines include some of the most played cards right now, this card makes an already strong batch of monsters OTK powerhouses. Machines are going to take a hit in some form this list so seeing this card move to banned would not be a suprise.

Mind Crush - As stated with Confiscation, this card's status could depend a lot on what happens to the cards around it. The fact that it potentially can be a 3 for 1 card and its comboability with cards like Confiscation and Trap Dustshoot will likely keep this card where it is. I see the safe approach being taken here.

Mirror Force - With the release of Radiant Mirror Force in Force of the Breaker, I would have sworn this card would be banned last list. It survived then, but can it do so again? Usually weaker versions replace the originals and the originals stay banned for life. However, Mirror Force is one of the few Mass Removal cards left in the game (with a minimal timing requirement). In decks that run few traps, Mirror Force is still the preferred choice. Radiant Mirror Force and Justi-Break seem to want to replace it, but like a few other cards, Mirror Force is a "necessary evil". Unless they seriously push for more of a 1 for 1 set of trades (back when Sakuretsu Armor and Widespread Ruin were both run in 3s), there isn't anything that can quite fill the place of Mirror Force. I would almost say that this card could earn a "permanent" place on Restrict List.

Morphing Jar - Most of the Jar cards have the ability to reset the game to some sort of a level playing field. Fiber Jar is the most obvious. Cyber Jar clears the field and gives both players 5 cards between the field and hand. Morphing Jar resets both player's hands to 5 cards. Like the other Jars, this can help and hurt you potentially at the same time. Because of the mass drawing power that this card offers, some are thinking this could be banned. I don't see that happenning. Maybe it might trade places with Cyber Jar, but other than that, it should simply stay here.

Mystical Space Typhoon - This card will be gone. With what I said about Heavy Storm and Structure Decks is more true here as it was in every Structure Deck from 1 through 12. We're getting Twister in SD13 instead. It's the simplest 1 for 1 Spell/Trap Removal card in the game. With the fact that they gave us 3 scaled back versions of this card (1 each in the last 3 sets), not to mention still having Dust Tornado and Nobleman of Extermination as far as non-theme specific cards, if there was ever a card that seemed to be a lock for going away, it is this one. The only thing that could possibly save this from being with the Ban Mallet is if Heavy Storm is banned and Harpie's Feather Duster stays banned as well. However, it genuinely feels that this one is gone.

Nobleman of Crossout - This card feels like it should stay at one. With the impending arrival of Shield Crush though, it's entirely possible that in order to make FLIP monsters more playable (as if they're really not already), this card could be banned and allow Shield Crush to fill that place. That would be a mistake though. It has it's own place in the game that it fills nicely. 1 is perfectly sufficient for this card.

Overload Fusion - Let's face it. This card isn't the problem. Chimeratech Overdragon was the problem. Even with Future Fusion (which is good in its own right in any fusion deck which is why it should stay restricted) and this restricted, Chimeratech Overdragon found a nice spot in machine decks as part of a game winning swing. Ban that card, and Overload Fusion should drop to Unrestricted as the only other cards it can fetch are Labyrinth Tank, Gatling Dragon, and Cyberdark Dragon (none of whom I'd call game breaking). It should be unrestricted but we all know this card's fate is totally dependant on Chimeratech Overdragon.

Ring of Destruction - Unbanned to help offset Cyber-Stein and even after that, it's still around. This card helps make games go very fast. While I get the feeling it will return back to being banned (as more than few are clamoring for), this stands a good chance at staying here. This will genuinely depend on which other cards they want to rotate off the list.

Sangan - Probably will still be here for 6 more months. While it is the best playable all-purpose searcher in the game, a number of decks have succeeded without using him. Not going anywhere unless they decide to do something crazy like switch it with Witch of the Black Forest.

Scapegoat - For everyone and their fantasy lists that say this should be unrestricted, get over it! Considering how much the OCG works on limiting stall cards, they're not about to make this card more playable. In a worst case, it functions as an alternative to Waboku. In a best case, it will function as a Waboku for 2-3 turns. Unless trample (sorry, piercing) ends up dominating, perhaps they'll do something with this card (though players would likely have abandoned it altogether). 1 is way more than enough for this.

Snatch Steal - You could hear the gnashing and crying when it was announced this card would be playable last ban list. Well, just lump it under Dark Hole as a card that got rotated off for some play and should be banned again once the season leaves. At least it wasn't Yata-Garasu. If you miss Snatch Steal that much, run Archfiends + Falling Down.

Treeborn Frog - That cry you might hear will be the collective disbelief (and disappointment) from the TCG if this card is not banned. It is the anchor card for just about every Monarch deck out there. The sad thing is that Treeborn Frog does give Tribute decks legitimate options. However, it appears the only option people chose was the Monarch option. Even if it is banned though, people will find other options though none are as useful as this one. In the end though, the Frog should end up keeping the Serpent company in the pond.

Lots of options as I said, and it really is hard to predict which way some cards can go. The ones most likely to be banned from this list: Mystical Space Typhoon, Snatch Steal, and Treeborn Frog. As far as cards becoming Semi/Unrestricted, there really isn't much here that looks like it would go that way. D.D. Warrior Lady and Overload Fusion probably are the most likely, but those will highly depend on other cards instead.

Discuss!
 
Densetsu_x, in my opinion, these are the cards among the ones you listed that have the best chance of being banned:

Limiter Removal - (in yer face, Chimeratech)

Mirror Force - I actually have mixed feelings about this one. It's kind of a 50-50 thing here with me on this card. True, there is Radiant Mirror Force and Justi-Break, but none can really replace this monster repellent.

Ring of Destruction - Yes, it ends games quickly. That's probably why it will be banned again. I sure hope not.

Snatch Steal - Well, this has been explained over a thousand times.

These are the cards that I think are gonna stay where they're at (Restricted at 1):

Book of Moon - Sure it would be a good counter to Monarch and Brain Control, but this combined with Tsukuyomi would be overkill. 1 is good. Enuff is Znuff. (ha, Enuff Znuff is the name of an antual band. ^_^)

Confiscation - I'm kinda on the whole "Mirror Force" thing with this card, but I feel it more of a 30-70 thing. With the 70 leaning towards staying where it is.

D.D. Warrior Lady - Sure, she is more versatile than D.D. Assailant, but that is why she should stay restricted.

Dark Magician of Chaos - I AM NOT!!!...going to rely on just MSE to get my spells back. I won't do it!

Dimension Fusion - I really don't see why it should be moved.

Giant Trunade - Yes, this card should stay. For too many reasons.

Heavy Storm - and remind me again...why should this be banned and replaced with Harpie's Feather Duster?!?!?!

Jinzo - Trap negation is always great, and not everyone has Royal Decree, you know. Plus, until we get a DARK monarch, he's the closest thing to one that we got.

Mind Crush - Huh?

Morphing Jar - Like the other jars (cept' Morphing Jar #2, he's the retarded cousin of the jars), he deserves to be high on the list, if not banned.

Mystical Space Typhoon - I don't see why it should be banned. Besides Heavy Storm and Mobius, it's all the S/T destruction we have (played mainstream anyway).

Nobleman of Crossout - Yea, Shield Crush won't replace this card, but it comes so close it's scary.

Sangan - Duh.

Scapegoat - Because Destiny Hero - Dasher needs a friend.

Treeborn Frog - Not only are Monarchs the only decks to utilize this monster (i agree though, they do use it the most), but several Tribute/Mausoleum/Phoenix/etc. Decks use it. And it fills the hole of Sinister Serpent nicely.

And now cards I think will be Semi-Restricted/Unrestricted:

Chain Strike - I can see it coming down to 2. And Chain burn decks might make a decent comeback.

Overload Fusion - This card should be unrestricted completely. But do something with Chimeartech...please?

So yeah. That's my opinion.

RESPOND!!!
 
Well to counter respond some.

Dark Magician of Chaos - You can always use "A Feather of the Phoenix" to get your Spells back ;)

Dimension Fusion - Part of the reasoning for this is because Norleras does have some success in the OCG. Plus honestly, RFP should actually be Removed From Play and not merely "The Other Graveyard".

Heavy Storm - Switching it with Harpie's Feather Duster would be just to let HFD be playable for a short bit, though I do have a feeling that Heavy Storm may go away soon.

And I've already stated why I think the Frog will be sent up the river.
 
i wish they would ban snipe hunter and have 2 or 3 night assailants.

snipe hunter should go to 1 regardless.
personally i would like to see tsukuyomi back.
 
I don't see how Heavy Storm can be banned just to allow Harpie's Feather Duster again. All that means is the latter "destroy your opponent's S/T cards" effect won't affect your own S/T cards, which is why HS needs to be played at the right time more so than HFD.

bigdevilyogi said:
i wish they would ban snipe hunter and have 2 or 3 night assailants.
A card with a discard cost and a gamble effect isn't going to be banned. I don't see Snipe Hunter being Limited, either, since you have to play it carefully, anyway. And if Night Assailant were no longer Limited, discard costs would be, well, free.
 
Book of Moon & Cyber Jar - keep them where they are, or i'll just remake mexi-mill & abuse them like crazy again (especially if Tsukuyomi & MOF comes off too) :D

Gravity Bind - I dont know why this got limited in the first place, it's NOT like they banned Royal Decree, Mobius, Dust Tornado or Snipe Hunter. Put GB at 2.

Chain Strike - Leave it where it is. I know how devastating even 2 can be.

Confiscation - Ban it

DDWL- Make her 3. It aint like anybody will play 3 of her anyways (like Exiled Force)

DMOC- No comment.

Dimension Fusion - Keep it on one

Giant Trunade - Keep it one one

Heavy Storm - 1 is good enough

Jinzo - Actually, semi-limit him. Its not like he cannot be killed by simple removal & he aint broke.

Morphing Jar & Card Destruction - Leave it. Don't put another "nail in the coffin" of DW decks pl0x.

Treeborn Frog - Ban it

Snipe Hunter - on ONE please

Night Assailant - on TWO please, so I can have a darn good reason to abuse Divine Wraths & Raigeki Breaks again :D

Ring & Snatch - WHY did they come back? they should have STAYED banned.

Scapegoats- at ONE pl0x, or else duelists are gonna have to run the "fuzzball gauntlet" to get to their opponent's LP's = BORING!!
 
Confiscation has but been guarenteed to stay where it is. We all know it won't be Semi-Restricted and it's been confirmed to be reprinted in Champion Pack: Game Four. And since they're not about to reprint a card that is about to be banned... Restricted to 1 it will stay.
 
And since they're not about to reprint a card that is about to be banned...
Why not? I remember them doing that to Painful Choice. :nyah
I just hope Confi gets banned, ah well I can dream I guess.
 
if they ban mst i kinda wish they'd bring breaker back...i could use a bit more things to use against card troopers...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top