I'm still not convinced at all that this is a real list. I'm perfectly aware that there are a bunch of "scans" etc. But in my experiences, I have seen realistic scans that turned out to be fake in the end. Also, the source is BBS to begin with, who were mostly responsible for the previous fake list. And I wouldn't consider a Geocities site to be "reliable".
For the fake March 1st list, everyone was convinced it was real, and had the most bizzare moves, two common moves with this list being Nobleman of Crossout at two and D.D. Assailant off the list. Sites such as Shriek somehow had it 100% confirmed yet was fake and other sites followed suit saying it was confirmed.
The moves seem similar to those that inexperienced players often suggest, which I find is more than just a coincidence. In other words, Metamorphosis being banned (which could have just been restricted again), Smashing Ground, Fissure and Brain Control limited (Book of Moon to three instead), Royal Decree and Destiny Hero - Malicious at two (not semi-limit worthy).
Gadgets certainly have not been dominating in Japan. They were high in frequency at their nationals, but did they win? No, Light and Darkness Dragon won. For other reported Japanese tournaments, Gadgets rarely see the light of day, and if they do, they don't usually win. Even though that running two seems to be more effective in most cases, the semi-limiting in that case is utterly pointless.
Destiny Hero - Disk Commander was rarely ran in two copies. If UDE/Konami were truly responsible for creating this list, they should have noticed that. Therefore, any limit on it would be again, pointless.
Now the most bizzare, The Transmigration Prophecy. Under no circumstances does this card deserve a limit. It has never seen competitive play ever, even in Japan so I have no idea why it would be under the banlist radar. Bringing back any card for the sole intention of reusing it is highly situational as you would have to redraw it. That one card is what makes me suspect this list is not reliable at all, despite the "scans".
Also, Protector of the Sanctuary going to three with Morphing Jar still legal? Other questions, why semi-limit Royal Decree when running a pair of Jinzo can be much better? Why semi-limit Malicious when Metamorphosis is banned? Why limit Trap Dustshoot when it was only decent because of the combo-metagame? And again, why on earth limit The Transmigration Prophecy?
The list is manageable, but the majority of the limits are not not limit-worthy in the least.
Just to note as well, I would rather see high-quality scans from a trustworthy member who has the alleged V-Jump magazine, instead of blurred images from a site responsible for the last fake list. [ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FyHn5mDUuzI]Here[/ame] even is a non-YGO related example where "scans" can be convincing, yet were confirmed fake.
Yes it could certainly be real and in that case it would only take adjusting to, but I'm not going to be convinced that it's legit until it is posted on at least the official Japanese YGO page at
http://www.yugioh-card.com/japan/tou/seigen08.html (Note: that is a dead link but should be link the newest list will be posted at).
