Search results

  1. A

    what EXACTLY is a chaos deck??

    As opposed to all the other types of decks wherein the goal is to use cards that offer no advantage?
  2. A

    Why isnt This Card Used ALOT More Often???

    The reason you don't see it more is the same reason you see few other tribute monsters in the majority of decks. They are costly to run and require you to give up field presence to get them out (especially a monster like Great Maju Garzett who needs a strong attacker to be tributed). Most...
  3. A

    A couple newb questions, please have a look! ^_^

    Simply follow rules of Priority and chaining. When you are the non-turn player you must wait for the opponent to begin a chain (then chain Skull Lair to it), or when they pass Priority to you you may activate it then.
  4. A

    A couple newb questions, please have a look! ^_^

    Skull Lair's initial activation (being flipped face-up) can be done pretty much without restriction following standard rules for activating traps (not the same round as set, not during damage step unless altering ATK/DEF, etc.) Skull Lair's actual effect can be activated (after it has been...
  5. A

    Infinite Loop??

    -edit- double post
  6. A

    Infinite Loop??

    Where was this definition acquired? An Infinite Loop has been previously defined by UDE/Konami as one without end. Please direct me to where you are getting information that it is okay to create an Infinite Loop as long as there is something else that will occur to benefit or damage one of the...
  7. A

    convulsion of nature+archfiends oath

    This isn't a complicated question Kyhotae. He was asking a straight foward "can this be activated under these conditions". Needing to know whether or not he would lose the game in the next instant doesn't enter into the discussion. You sound way too much like UDE and the "don't come to us...
  8. A

    Infinite Loop??

    It wouldn't be destroyed. Cyber Phoenix only negates the card (which in no way means it isn't equipped just that it is being negated). Snatch Steal would not be allowed to be activated at all because that would be purposely starting an infinite loop (which is not allowed). It doesn't matter...
  9. A

    Gearfired the Iron Knight and Fusion Sword Murasame Blade

    I wouldn't doubt it DJ but see how it is played up as "proactive" on their part that they "took it off the site until they could get further information from Konami". Come on guys. You leave things on the site for years that are obviously not congruent with the other "official rulings"...
  10. A

    BTH being activated after TP announces he wants to proceed to BP

    Kevin does not make rules. Kevin has never made rules (okay he makes up rules but then gets in trouble for passing out erroneous information when Konami calls him on it). Pineapple Blast is a perfect example just like the Bottomless Trap Hole/Torrential Tribute example previously in this...
  11. A

    Gearfired the Iron Knight and Fusion Sword Murasame Blade

    I just wish they would remove other rulings that obviously can't be correct. It is puzzling that this one got yanked prior to confirmation with Konami when so often we've been told that they can't remove a known erroneous ruling because they have not received confirmation from Konami...
  12. A

    BTH being activated after TP announces he wants to proceed to BP

    I understood the Battle Step to be more of a: 1. Declare Attack 2. Start a chain (if you intend to do so) 3. If you do not wish to begin a chain you are passing priority by stating "I'd like to move on to the Damage Step". This isn't quite the same situation we have with Main Phase...
  13. A

    BTH being activated after TP announces he wants to proceed to BP

    If you are activating a Trap/Quickplay in Main Phase (at the end) then you are still in the Main Phase. The Turn Player says "I would like to end Main Phase 1 and go into Battle Phase. The NTP says "Before you end Main Phase 1 I'll activate ________." Thus you have not left Main Phase 1...
  14. A

    BTH being activated after TP announces he wants to proceed to BP

    Okay, before we swing way too far out here. Many remember when Kevin was telling people they could use Turn Player Priority to activate Pot of Greed. He was then told by Konami that that was not legal it had to be Speed 2 or a Monster Effect to use Turn Player Priority after the summon. Thus...
  15. A

    BTH being activated after TP announces he wants to proceed to BP

    It "works" in spite of having a clear ruling. Depending on where you are at any given time the Judge will have to choose A or B. That doesn't mean the system "works". It just means that in the overall picture it is a small enough mechanic that it shouldn't cause major havoc. What the...
  16. A

    Mobius, Scapegoat and Torrential Tribute

    This goes back to the "timing" for a summon negator. This has been done to death and really doesn't need to be brought back up as it has been firmly established that the timing is not the same for Horn of Heaven and for Bottomless Trap Hole. The negator is activated "before" the summon is...
  17. A

    mirror force

    No, Mirror Force does not negate the attack, it just destroys the monster (and any other Attack position monsters on your opponent's side of the field). If you are attacking with a monster that will survive the destruction the attack will still go through.
  18. A

    replay

    Asura Priest has no restriction for having to attack consecutively. It is in his rulings that he can indeed allow other monsters to attack and then continue attacking any other valid targets.
  19. A

    Organizational Skillz

    Oh goodie, pics of a collection from a first rate sorting fanatic. Now I can prove to my wife that I'm not that bad! :)
  20. A

    Organizational Skillz

    Wow! DJP, just wow! Mine just got a face-lift because my wife hated the white 3-ring binders I used to have them in. I'm now using Photography binders (so they look nicer on the bookshelf). 9 pocket sleeves sorted alphabetically by Effect Monsters, Effect Ritual Monsters, Effect Fusion...
Back
Top