Search results

Isn't choosing a monster for Last Turn Mandatory? I don't see the difference between that and creature swap. If Creature Swap worked the way that you are suggesting that Last Turn works, I would in theory play create Swap, remove the one monster that I have on the field, and get one of my...

Just to note on question # 4. Last Turn will only continue to resolve, if the Player activating it has another monster that can be selected at resolution. If you removed their only monster, they would be unable to select anything, and the entire effect of Last Turn would dissappear (This is...

I am arguing that "Until end of turn" is not an effect in and of an effect, but rather a duration of an existing effect. Why can't the effect of Change of Heart simply expire at the end of the turn? Are you arguing that "Until end of Turn", should really be interputed as "Change of...

First of all, I was using the ruling of Forzen Soul in my last post to explain why Last Turn can't create a new phase of gameplay, unless that ruling is wrong. The first ruiling of Frozen soul States "While "Frozen Soul" is in effect, you cannot activate "Last Turn" in the same turn because...

What is the difference? Spiritualism says nothing that stops its activation from being prevented, only negated. Since SC is preventing it from being played the how can Spiritualism work, since you would be unable to even activate it? Also, doesn't stopping the activation of all Spell cards...

Digital Jedi said "I would agree with you on this one, Novastar, but for one thing." "Spell Canceller's effect could indeed be interpreted differently if it in fact said: "Niether player may activate Spell Cards." or "Both players may not activate Spell Cards." In which case, it would...

Bishp said "A new phase is not being created here (despite my bad choice of wording before -- corrected now). And, again, just because A does not mean B. Just because you don't see that the mechanics of the game allow something does not mean that a card effect cannot override those mechanics."...

Actually, Spell Canceller's text says "As long as this card remains face up on the field, all Spell Cards cannote be activated. The effects of all face up Spell Cards are also negated."

I know that UDE says this, but Spell Canceler's text clearly states that spell cards cannot be activated while it is face up on the field. This is the same thing that happenes with Sonic jammer, expect that the latter only lasts for a limited amount of time.

I actually forgot about weather report. That being said, I still don't get why it was ruled that a whole new phase was created by Last Turn. There is currently nothing in the mechanics of the game that allows for this, nor is there any errta on Last Turn that I can find. Battle phase is still...

Don't forget about Spell Canceler. Its first effect saya that Spell cards can not be activated.

Digital Jedi said "Change of Heart Select 1 monster on your opponent's side of the field. Take control of the selected monster until the End Phase of this turn. " "Mind Control Take control of 1 monster on your opponent's side of the field until the End Phase. This monster cannot declare an...

Actually, that is not correct. Cards Like Last Turn which has the player(s) select monster(s) have them do so at resolution, not activation. Thus, in this case, Jowgen would have already switch control before the player activation Last Turn would be allowed to select his monster. In cases...

How does Last Turn Create a new Phase of Game Play? There is nothing in the game that I can think of that allows for a card to create a new phase of gameplay (espically for that card only). How is this new gamephase created anyway, and why? Since card effects can and sometimes do force...

Actually, if Player A had no monsters on the field and couldn't selecet one, then the entire effect of Last Turn would dissappear. It's on the judge's list I believe.

I only mentioned Remove Brainwashing to make to rasie of question of why a monster that always knows who its original owner is can forget who it was stolen from when it is flipped face down. Wouldn't the monster need to know who its original owner was for Remove Brainwashing to work, since as...

The point that I was trying to make before, which I guess I need to make clearer, is that there are two things that occur after the stolen monster is flipped face down. One is that Snatch Steal is destoried by game mechanics, and the other is that the status of the stolen monster needs to be...

How does the equip insignia of Snatch Steal determine its target? Please correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the player who played Snatch Steal determine the target at the time of activation. As far as I can see, the only think that the equip insignia on Snatch Steal does is to inform the...

So, if I understand you correctly, your argument in favor of the flipped down monster not returning to its original contorler is that becase the target of Snatch Steal (which was face up to begin) can no longer be determined. I believe however, that the original target of Snatch Steal can be...

Isn't also a game mechanic that also states that a monster that is flipped face down also has its effects reset? This why for example, I can use Book of Moon ot Mirage Knight to keep it from being removed from the game by its own effect after it is involved in a battle. This would seen to...